top of page
The pre-order for Thanksgiving is now closed. I'll be posting some cute holiday options in the next few weeks for December!
Menu items are available with a 3 day minimum pre-order (you can always try for next day, I just can't guarantee it!)
Special orders (decorated sugar cookies, cakes etc) are fully booked for November. Now is the time to reach about December/January birthdays!
Follow me on Instagram and Facebook for updated last minute specials. Instagram: @bookendbaker Facebook: thebookendbaker
I am now including delivery fees in Orchard Park. Pick-up is always an easy option!
Cookies and Bars
Cookie Combo Pack
Pick any 6 cookies for a sampler box. These are BIG cookies. You will eat them all but you won't regret it. List your choices under "special requests" on the order form. Please message me if interested in placing a large order for a party. The pricing will go down with bulk orders.
$25
Sherry's Cookie Subscription Plan
My neighbor Sherry came up with this genius subscription. This is for those of you who LOVE a cookie, but would rather not battle the temptation of a whole box of cookies. One cookie a week, popped in your mailbox or on your front porch, during the day on Wednesday. You can either alert me to a specific cookie that you want the Tuesday before delivery OR tempt fate and be surprised. Each subscription lasts 5 weeks. ***Delivery for residents of Orchard Park only. If you aren't in OP and would like to subscribe to a cookie a week, it will be pick-up in OP****
$30
Fat Pete Cookies
4 Giant Peanut Butter Cookies. I can't even express how good these are. I added both homemade peanut brittle AND chunks of caramelized pretzel to the dough, and then stuffed it with a ball of bittersweet chocolate fudge. Pete is not fat, but he will be (and happy) if he keeps eating these!
$18
Cookie Tray
A selection of 12 of my giant drop cookies (found listed in the Cookie section of the menu), sliced in half and ready for sharing at a party!
$50
The Elsie
The Elsie is a dark chocolate cookie, filled with a chocolate cherry fudge, and topped with a cherry glaze. 4 cookies per order!
$18
The Hefty
4 large Cinnamon Sugar cookies, filled with orange-scented maple walnut fudge, and chunks of candied ritz cracker for buttery crunch.
$18
PYO Sugar Cookies
These are the CUTEST treat options for a party EVER. I've got a variety of images available. Each cookie comes packaged with a paintbrush, instructions, and an edible watercolor sheet! Orders accepted for 6 or more cookies. Please allow 5 days notice when ordering. Email me at thebookendbaker@gmail.com with questions
$6
The Kimbo
4 Kimbos per order. The old Kimbo cookie has risen from the ashes like a beautiful, buttery Phoenix to become my new favorite cookie!!! Chocolate Chip cookie dough with caramelized pretzel chunks, filled with homemade dulce de leche. I can't even. I short nuke in the microwave would definitely be a smart move.
$18
Americana Apple Cookie
4 cookies per order, or add to a combo pack! This cookie tastes like all the best bits of a cookie and an apple pie joined forces to make a super cookie: A brown sugary, apple cidery, spiced sugar cookie base, with chunks of candied graham cracker for a little "pie crust" crunch, and a filling that screams "I won the County Fair pie/cookie contest!" This might be my new favorite cookie.
$18
Tastes Like Victory!
4 large dark chocolate cookies with a chocolate mocha fudge core, studded with white chocolate chips, and topped with a sugar cookie crust. Go Bills!
$18
M&M Cookies
M&M cookies on sale this week! 4 LARGE cookies per order. Candy in a cookie is never a bad thing!
$14
Old School Chocolate Chip
4 large perfect Chocolate Chip cookies, loaded with semisweet, milk, and dark chocolate chips.
$16
The Happy Pat
4 cookies per order. A chocolate cookie studded with caramelized pretzel chunks, and filled with peanut butter fudge. Money can't buy you happiness, but this cookie can.
$18
S'mores Cookies!
The Girl Scouts had the right idea with these flavors! 4 S'mores cookies: caramelized graham cracker pieces in a wheaty, cinnamony graham dough, with chocolate chips and a marshmallow center!
$18
The Lunch Box
4 Large Cookies. My peanut butter cookie base, swirled with marshmallow fluff, and stuffed with a marshmallow center. It's the fluffernutter of your childhood dreams.
$18
Baby whoopie pies
One dozen 2-inch dark chocolate whoopie pies, filled with an airy, marshmallowy vanilla center.
$30
Glazed Gingerbread Cookies
One Dozen glazed gingerbread cookies. These soft, warmly spiced cookies with a sweet glaze are perfect any time of year. Cookies will be fall shapes!
$39
Shortbread Biscuits
5 buttery-simple shortbread biscuits. Nothing is better.
$10
Large Double Decker
One 8 inch double layer cookie cake. Choose your cookie flavor! Cookie flavors: chocolate chip, cinnamon sugar, sprinkle, peanut butter, chocolate. Feel free to choose two different flavors.
$40
Small Double Decker
Two 6 inch cookies stacked and filled with swiss meringue buttercream. Choose up to two cookie flavors: chocolate chip, sprinkle, peanut butter, cinnamon sugar, chocolate
$25
bottom of page